Showing posts with label George Monbiot. Show all posts
Showing posts with label George Monbiot. Show all posts

Sunday, July 15, 2012

I was curious after my George Monbiot, you swine… post as to what George’s thoughts on libertarianism since we do share common beliefs. So, I did a search of his blog on the term libertarian and came up with subject headings such as:

Libertarians are the True Social Parasites
The Anti-Social Bastards in Our Midst

Yep, we are on the same page on libertarianism as well.

When it comes to the description of parasites, George should know since he is an Oxford educated zoologist. The concept that people will work well “if they can get government off our backs” is challenged by George in a case of what I call the ladder principle, which is where one uses the governmental system to prosper and then pulls the ladder up so that no one else can follow. In the case of one Libertarian, he was against government intrusion in the market, until his bank needed help!

The problem is that there needs to be some form of government, which libertarians decry as statism. But the government can be society at large. The libertarian prefers to not live within society’s norms. Of course, as Geoge Monbiot points out, libertarians are all too interested in using the system’s institutions against the system for their self-interest. For example, the Cato Institute used the Court system to rewrite the constitution in the Heller-McDonald cases. I am not sure what to think of the aspect that the Court did more than just interpret the constitution and the populace at large failed to notice that.

My personal experience of libertarians is that they are the ones who scream loudly of freedom, but do their best to intrude upon other’s freedom and security. Naturally, that comment would attract claims from the libertarian crowd that my support for gun control is “anti-liberty”. I counter that with among other things the fact that security checkpoints are common in US public buildings and people live in fear of being shot. Even more saliently, the Second Amendment was written to prevent a large military, not to ensure private arms outside the militia context.

MY impetus to write this is a response to a post at Daisy’s Dead Air where she mentions incest. My opinion is that she is confusing liberals and libertarians. My first encounter with libertarians was that a class mate had libertarian parents. The parents gave their kids pornography and tolerated behaviour which turned out to be the son molesting the daughter. I blame it on the libertarian dislike of the nanny state and calling incest a “victimless crime”.

In reading the Maclean’s article Daisy mentions, it sounds like the libertarian viewpoint. The first comment bears that out:
I agree wholeheartedly with the commentator. I think is a clear example of government overreach. There is no reason to criminalize incest. There is no need to deter people from doing it, since most people are naturally repulsed by it.
The article and the comments have that “intrusive government” aspect which is libertarianism.

As opposed to “Statists” who believe in things such as laws…And conventions of society.

Likewise, as a Green, I have a strong distrust of libertarianism since it is a pro-industry viewpoint. They argue such things as global temperatures have scarcely increased, so we should stop worrying about climate change. They suggest that elephants should be hunted for their ivory, planning laws should be scrapped, recycling should be stopped, bosses should be free to choose whether or not their workers contract repetitive strain injury and companies, rather than governments, should be allowed to decide whether or not the food they sell is safe. They rage against taxes, subsidies, bail-outs and government regulation. Well, bail-outs to the point that the libertarian requires them–then they are acceptable.

I will end by quoting George:
Wherever modern humans, living outside the narrow social mores of the clan, are allowed to pursue their genetic interests without constraint, they will hurt other people. They will grab other people’s resources, they will dump their waste in other people’s habitats, they will cheat, lie, steal and kill. And if they have power and weapons, no one will be able to stop them except those with more power and better weapons. Our genetic inheritance makes us smart enough to see that when the old society breaks down, we should appease those who are more powerful than ourselves, and exploit those who are less powerful. The survival strategies which once ensured cooperation among equals now ensure subservience to those who have broken the social contract.

The democratic challenge, which becomes ever more complex as the scale of human interactions increases, is to mimic the governance system of the small hominid troop. We need a state that rewards us for cooperating and punishes us for cheating and stealing. At the same time we must ensure that the state is also treated like a member of the hominid clan and punished when it acts against the common good. Human welfare, just as it was a million years ago, is guaranteed only by mutual scrutiny and regulation.

I doubt that libertarians would be able to sustain their beliefs in a place where the state has broken down. Unless tax-payers’ money and public services are available to repair the destruction it causes, libertarianism destroys people’s savings, wrecks their lives and trashes their environment. It is the belief system of the free-rider, who is perpetually subsidised by responsible citizens. As biologists we both know what this means. Self-serving as governments might be, the true social parasites are those who demand their dissolution.
And add that in a democracy, the people ARE the government, which makes me even more suspicious of the libertarian dislike for “government” and “the State”.

“L’etat c’est moi”..et toi (vous?).

Friday, July 13, 2012

Since I mention The Fifty Cent Army

I thought I would repost from my blog: 

George Monbiot, you swine…

You beat me to writing a piece on this topic and did it in a way that was really close to how I would have written the piece.

George and I are pretty much in agreement about most things, which is the reason I titled this the way I did since it is jest that I am describing him as a swine (and I’m a dog). I guess great minds think alike. And I concede  that  George is much more plugged in, but his post Reclaim the Cyber-Commons is pretty close to something I’ve had sitting around as a draft. But I have to tell him his tag line:
Tell people something they know already and they will thank you for it.
Tell them something new and they will hate you for it.
is a little off in this case.  I totally agree with him when he makes this point and would have started my post the same way:
The weapon used by both state and corporate players is a technique known as astroturfing. An astroturf campaign is one that mimics spontaneous grassroots mobilisations, but which has in reality been organised. Anyone writing a comment piece in Mandarin critical of the Chinese government, for example, is likely to be bombarded with abuse by people purporting to be ordinary citizens, upset by the slurs against their country.

But many of them aren’t upset: they are members of the 50 Cent Party, so-called because one Chinese government agency pays 5 mao (half a yuan) for every post its tame commenters write. Teams of these sock-puppets are hired by party leaders to drown out critical voices and derail intelligent debates.
George learned about online astroturfing in 2002, when the investigators Andy Rowell and Jonathan Matthews looked into a series of comments made by two people calling themselves Mary Murphy and Andura Smetacek. These two people had launched ferocious attacks, across several internet forums, against a scientist whose research suggested that Mexican corn had been widely contaminated by GM pollen. Rowell and Matthews found that one of the messages Mary Murphy had sent came from a domain owned by the Bivings Group, a PR company specialising in internet lobbying.

And anyone who blogs about unpopular topics such as Palestinian Rights or Gun Control knows, you will be inundated by comments challenging your beliefs. George points out that:
Reading comment threads on the Guardian’s sites and elsewhere on the web, two patterns jump out at me. The first is that discussions of issues in which there’s little money at stake tend to be a lot more civilised than debates about issues where companies stand to lose or gain
I'm with him...but I'm watching what I say when we're at dinner parites
billions: such as climate change, public health and corporate tax avoidance. These are often characterised by amazing levels of abuse and disruption.

Articles about the environment are hit harder by such tactics than any others. I love debate, and I often wade into the threads beneath my columns. But it’s a depressing experience, as instead of contesting the issues I raise, many of those who disagree bombard me with infantile abuse, or just keep repeating a fiction, however often you discredit it. This ensures that an intelligent discussion is almost impossible – which appears to be the point.

The second pattern is the strong association between this tactic and a certain set of views: pro-corporate, anti-tax, anti-regulation. Both traditional conservatives and traditional progressives tend be more willing to discuss an issue than these right-wing libertarians, many of whom seek instead to shut down debate.

So what’s going on? I’m not suggesting that most of the people trying to derail these discussions are paid to do so, though I would be surprised if none were. I’m suggesting that some of the efforts to prevent intelligence from blooming seem to be organised, and that neither website hosts nor other commenters know how to respond.
I have to admit that if I had written my piece on Astroturf, I would have also borrowed from George where he talks about the people who aren’t paid, but who are willing to shill for the PR firms that  do the internet astroturfing by repeating their messages. They are the committed, although, I do wonder as to how many are truly concerned individuals since they rarely bother me after I started posting IP addresses! So, I am in agreement with you that the keyboard warriors who do post here are truly individual, but rare.

But, since you beat me to it, George, I’m going to borrow from you. Especially since you mention this:
For his film (Astro)Turf Wars, Taki Oldham secretly recorded a training session organised by a rightwing libertarian group called American Majority. The trainer, Austin James, was instructing Tea Party members on how to “manipulate the medium”. This is what he told them:

“Here’s what I do. I get on Amazon; I type in “Liberal Books”. I go through and I say “one star, one star, one star”. The flipside is you go to a conservative/ libertarian whatever, go to their products and give them five stars. … This is where your kids get information: Rotten Tomatoes, Flixster. These are places where you can rate movies. So when you type in “Movies on Healthcare”, I don’t want Michael Moore’s to come up, so I always give it bad ratings. I spend about 30 minutes a day, just click, click, click, click. … If there’s a place to comment, a place to rate, a place to share information, you have to do it. That’s how you control the online dialogue and give our ideas a fighting chance.”

Over 75% of the funding for American Majority, which hosted this training session, comes from the Sam Adams Alliance. In 2008, the year in which American Majority was founded, 88% of the alliance’s money came from a single donation, of $3.7m. A group which trains rightwing libertarians to distort online democratic processes, in other words, was set up with funding from a person or company with a very large wallet.
I wish that George would allow for comments since I want to give him a hand for putting out something that I will admit is a much better version than what I had written. More importantly, I think that what George has written needs to be published so that more people are aware of how debate is being stifled: especially since he neglect subjects where this practise is widespread (non-inclusive list of where I add the issues of  Palestinian rights, gun control to the ones George mentions).

George, this is the exception that proves the rule.  So, a grudging thank you for telling me something I knew already and saving me a lot of work in actually writing it by beating me to the punch here. I hope you don’t mind me passing it on with my own comments.

OK, George, I borrowed from you. I hope that you will borrow from my post The Centre for Alternative Technology is in financial straits. After all, they are in your neck of the woods.
I think you can get the proper audience for that message.

See also:

Wednesday, August 31, 2011

Introduction to George Monbiot

On Trying To Be Less Wrong

By George Monbiot. Published on monbiot.com, 28th June 2011

My job is to tell people what they don’t want to hear. That is not what I set out to do. I wanted only to cover the subjects I thought were interesting and important. But wherever I turned, I met a brick wall of denial.

Denial is everywhere. I have come to believe that it’s an intrinsic component of our humanity, an essential survival strategy. Unlike other species, we know that we will die. This knowledge could destroy us, were we unable to blot it out. But, unlike other species, we also know how not to know. We employ this unique ability to suppress our knowledge not just of mortality, but of everything we find uncomfortable, until our survival strategy becomes a threat to our survival.

Whenever I have tried to bring an awkward issue to public attention, it has been greeted with a cacophony of voices insisting that there is nothing to worry about. The volume of denial bears no relationship – except perhaps a positive one – to the strength of the evidence.

Denial is exacerbated by the nature of the media. I believe that the purpose of journalism is to hold power to account. But it is used, overwhelmingly, to support power against those who challenge it. Most media organisations are owned by very wealthy people or corporations. They appoint editors in their own image, and the people who work for them are acutely aware of where their interests lie. One of the privileges of wealth is that you can employ other people to engage in denial on your behalf. Ideas and information which conflict with the interests of the proprietorial class, or upset their assumptions, are either energetically denounced or comprehensively ignored by their employees.

Just as journalists seldom hold power to account, there are few means by which the power of journalists is held to account. The internet, paradoxically, has made journalism less accountable, as it exacerbates the tendency for like-minded people to clump together, and to shout down or shut out the voices which challenge them. Journalists – especially commentators – attract loyal followers, who defend them from criticism. They quickly learn what their followers want to hear. They can change their opinions only at the cost of alienating their fans. Even if their claims are repeatedly exposed as false, they must stick to the script. Nothing destroys good journalism more effectively than being treated as a hero.

It is not just power that journalists should challenge: they should also challenge themselves. Before making any claim, we should ask ourselves whether the evidence supports our beliefs. When we discover that we have got something wrong, we must be prepared to say so. Being able to abandon pride and admit that we are wrong is the only hope we have of acquiring wisdom. That is another way of saying that it’s the only hope we have of creating a better world.

The evidence is not fixed. The facts change as new findings are made, and as societies, technologies and power relations change. Identities are not fixed either. People can be victims at one moment, oppressors at another. There is no virtue in sustaining a set of beliefs, regardless of the evidence. There is no virtue in either following other people unquestioningly or in cultivating a loyal and unquestioning band of followers.

While you can be definitively wrong, you cannot be definitely right. The best anyone can do is constantly to review the evidence and to keep improving and updating their knowledge. Journalism which attempts this is worth reading. Journalism which does not is a waste of time.

Just as importantly, journalists should show how they reach their conclusions, by providing sources for the facts they cite. Trust no one, but trust least those who cannot provide references. A charlatan, in any field, is someone who will not show you his records.

So, in reading the articles on this site, don’t expect to agree – or to disagree – with all of them. I no longer agree with all of them myself. You will find consistencies but also stark contradictions between some of the things I believed a few years ago, and some of the things I believe today.

I have tried to navigate and understand a world that is extraordinarily complex. The useful skill I possess is an ability to read and process a lot of information quickly: on average, I read around 600 pages of source material for every column I write. But this is nowhere near enough. The world’s complexity, and the impossibility of mastering any subject, let alone of achieving a comprehensive overview, means that we will always be wrong in some respects.

A complex system cannot produce simple or consistent answers. A system created by human beings – or by any conceivable entity – cannot produce perfect answers. Every choice we make involves pay-offs and compromises. This is a lesson I have learnt slowly and reluctantly.

But while my opinions about particular issues have changed and become more complex, my underlying principles have not. These are that we should stand up for the victims, whoever they might be, and against the aggressors, whoever they might be. We should defend the poor against the rich, the powerless against the powerful, the defenceless against the armed. We should defend the biosphere that gives us life: both because it is wonderful and because those of us who possess agency (who are alive today and have money) have no right to deprive others (who are not yet born or who are poor) of their means of survival. We must treat other people as we would wish to be treated ourselves.

None of these aims can be passively achieved. All involve confrontation. Among other forms of conflict, they require confrontation with denial – our own and other people’s – and with the falsehoods of those who possess power. This is where I have a role. The articles on this site are my stumbling attempts to confront power with research, and to tell the stories you would prefer not to hear.

Astroturf

A while back, I had a post that I had sitting around as a draft on this topic. Then George Monbiot wrote a piece on the topic in a way that was really close to how I would have written the piece.

George and I are pretty much in agreement about most things. I guess great minds think alike. And I concede that George is much more plugged in, but his post Reclaim the Cyber-Commons is pretty close to something I've had sitting around as a draft. But I have to tell him his tag line:
Tell people something they know already and they will thank you for it.
Tell them something new and they will hate you for it.
is a little off in this case. I totally agree with him when he makes this point and would have started my post the same way:
The weapon used by both state and corporate players is a technique known as astroturfing. An astroturf campaign is one that mimics spontaneous grassroots mobilisations, but which has in reality been organised. Anyone writing a comment piece in Mandarin critical of the Chinese government, for example, is likely to be bombarded with abuse by people purporting to be ordinary citizens, upset by the slurs against their country.

But many of them aren’t upset: they are members of the 50 Cent Party, so-called because one Chinese government agency pays 5 mao (half a yuan) for every post its tame commenters write. Teams of these sock-puppets are hired by party leaders to drown out critical voices and derail intelligent debates.

George learned about online astroturfing in 2002, when the investigators Andy Rowell and Jonathan Matthews looked into a series of comments made by two people calling themselves Mary Murphy and Andura Smetacek. These two people had launched ferocious attacks, across several internet forums, against a scientist whose research suggested that Mexican corn had been widely contaminated by GM pollen. Rowell and Matthews found that one of the messages Mary Murphy had sent came from a domain owned by the Bivings Group, a PR company specialising in internet lobbying.

And anyone who blogs about unpopular topics such as Palestinian Rights or Gun Control knows, you will be inundated by comments challenging your beliefs. George points out that:
Reading comment threads on the Guardian’s sites and elsewhere on the web, two patterns jump out at me. The first is that discussions of issues in which there’s little money at stake tend to be a lot more civilised than debates about issues where companies stand to lose or gain

billions: such as climate change, public health and corporate tax avoidance. These are often characterised by amazing levels of abuse and disruption.

Articles about the environment are hit harder by such tactics than any others. I love debate, and I often wade into the threads beneath my columns. But it’s a depressing experience, as instead of contesting the issues I raise, many of those who disagree bombard me with infantile abuse, or just keep repeating a fiction, however often you discredit it. This ensures that an intelligent discussion is almost impossible - which appears to be the point.

The second pattern is the strong association between this tactic and a certain set of views: pro-corporate, anti-tax, anti-regulation. Both traditional conservatives and traditional progressives tend be more willing to discuss an issue than these right-wing libertarians, many of whom seek instead to shut down debate.

So what’s going on? I’m not suggesting that most of the people trying to derail these discussions are paid to do so, though I would be surprised if none were. I’m suggesting that some of the efforts to prevent intelligence from blooming seem to be organised, and that neither website hosts nor other commenters know how to respond.

I have to admit that if I had written my piece on Astroturf, I would have also borrowed from George where he talks about the people who aren't paid, but who are willing to shill for the PR firms that do the internet astroturfing by repeating their messages. They are the committed, although, I do wonder as to how many are truly concerned individuals since they rarely bother me after I started posting IP addresses! So, I am in agreement with you that the keyboard warriors who do post here are truly individual, but rare.

But, since you beat me to it, George, I'm going to borrow from you. Especially since you mention this:
For his film (Astro)Turf Wars, Taki Oldham secretly recorded a training session organised by a rightwing libertarian group called American Majority. The trainer, Austin James, was instructing Tea Party members on how to “manipulate the medium”. This is what he told them:

“Here’s what I do. I get on Amazon; I type in “Liberal Books”. I go through and I say “one star, one star, one star”. The flipside is you go to a conservative/ libertarian whatever, go to their products and give them five stars. … This is where your kids get information: Rotten Tomatoes, Flixster. These are places where you can rate movies. So when you type in “Movies on Healthcare”, I don’t want Michael Moore’s to come up, so I always give it bad ratings. I spend about 30 minutes a day, just click, click, click, click. … If there’s a place to comment, a place to rate, a place to share information, you have to do it. That’s how you control the online dialogue and give our ideas a fighting chance.”

Over 75% of the funding for American Majority, which hosted this training session, comes from the Sam Adams Alliance. In 2008, the year in which American Majority was founded, 88% of the alliance’s money came from a single donation, of $3.7m. A group which trains rightwing libertarians to distort online democratic processes, in other words, was set up with funding from a person or company with a very large wallet.

I wish that George would allow for comments since I want to give him a hand for putting out something that I will admit is a much better version than what I had written. More importantly, I think that what George has written needs to be published so that more people are aware of how debate is being stifled: especially since he neglect subjects where this practise is widespread (non-inclusive list of where I add the issues of Palestinian rights, gun control to the ones George mentions).

George, this is the exception that proves the rule. So, a grudging thank you for telling me something I knew already and saving me a lot of work in actually writing it by beating me to the punch here. I hope you don't mind me passing it on with my own comments (he doesn't).

OK, George, I borrowed from you. I hope that you will borrow from my post The Centre for Alternative Technology is in financial straits. After all, they are in your neck of the woods.

I think you can get the proper audience for that message.

See also:

Wednesday, August 24, 2011

Great Minds think alike

(I was looking for one of my "Libertarianism is only right wing anarchy" posts and only found this)

I was curious after my George Monbiot, you swine… post as to what George's thoughts on libertarianism since we do share common beliefs. So, I did a search of his blog on the term libertarian and came up with subject headings such as:

Libertarians are the True Social Parasites
The Anti-Social Bastards in Our Midst

Yep, we are on the same page on libertarianism as well.

When it comes to the description of parasites, George should know since he is an Oxford educated zoologist. The concept that people will work well "if they can get government off our backs" is challenged by George in a case of what I call the ladder principle, which is where one uses the governmental system to prosper and then pulls the ladder up so that no one else can follow. In the case of one Libertarian, he was against government intrusion in the market, until his bank needed help!

The problem is that there needs to be some form of government, which libertarians decry as statism. But the government can be society at large. The libertarian prefers to not live within society's norms. Of course, as Geoge Monbiot points out, libertarians are all too interested in using the system's institutions against the system for their self-interest. For example, the Cato Institute used the Court system to rewrite the constitution in the Heller-McDonald cases. I am not sure what to think of the aspect that the Court did more than just interpret the constitution and the populace at large failed to notice that.

My personal experience of libertarians is that they are the ones who scream loudly of freedom, but do their best to intrude upon other's freedom and security. Naturally, that comment would attract claims from the libertarian crowd that my support for gun control is "anti-liberty". I counter that with among other things the fact that security checkpoints are common in US public buildings and people live in fear of being shot. Even more saliently, the Second Amendment was written to prevent a large military, not to ensure private arms outside the militia context.

MY impetus to write this is a response to a post at Daisy's Dead Air where she mentions incest. My opinion is that she is confusing liberals and libertarians. My first encounter with libertarians was that a class mate had libertarian parents. The parents gave their kids pornography and tolerated behaviour which turned out to be the son molesting the daughter. I blame it on the libertarian dislike of the nanny state and calling incest a "victimless crime".

In reading the Maclean's article Daisy mentions, it sounds like the libertarian viewpoint. The first comment bears that out:
I agree wholeheartedly with the commentator. I think is a clear example of government overreach. There is no reason to criminalize incest. There is no need to deter people from doing it, since most people are naturally repulsed by it.
The article and the comments have that "intrusive government" aspect which is libertarianism.

As opposed to "Statists" who believe in things such as laws...And conventions of society.

Likewise, as a Green, I have a strong distrust of libertarianism since it is a pro-industry viewpoint. They argue such things as global temperatures have scarcely increased, so we should stop worrying about climate change. They suggest that elephants should be hunted for their ivory, planning laws should be scrapped, recycling should be stopped, bosses should be free to choose whether or not their workers contract repetitive strain injury and companies, rather than governments, should be allowed to decide whether or not the food they sell is safe. They rage against taxes, subsidies, bail-outs and government regulation. Well, bail-outs to the point that the libertarian requires them--then they are acceptable.

I will end by quoting George:
Wherever modern humans, living outside the narrow social mores of the clan, are allowed to pursue their genetic interests without constraint, they will hurt other people. They will grab other people’s resources, they will dump their waste in other people’s habitats, they will cheat, lie, steal and kill. And if they have power and weapons, no one will be able to stop them except those with more power and better weapons. Our genetic inheritance makes us smart enough to see that when the old society breaks down, we should appease those who are more powerful than ourselves, and exploit those who are less powerful. The survival strategies which once ensured cooperation among equals now ensure subservience to those who have broken the social contract.

The democratic challenge, which becomes ever more complex as the scale of human interactions increases, is to mimic the governance system of the small hominid troop. We need a state that rewards us for cooperating and punishes us for cheating and stealing. At the same time we must ensure that the state is also treated like a member of the hominid clan and punished when it acts against the common good. Human welfare, just as it was a million years ago, is guaranteed only by mutual scrutiny and regulation.

I doubt that libertarians would be able to sustain their beliefs in a place where the state has broken down. Unless tax-payers’ money and public services are available to repair the destruction it causes, libertarianism destroys people’s savings, wrecks their lives and trashes their environment. It is the belief system of the free-rider, who is perpetually subsidised by responsible citizens. As biologists we both know what this means. Self-serving as governments might be, the true social parasites are those who demand their dissolution.
And add that in a democracy, the people ARE the government, which makes me even more suspicious of the libertarian dislike for "government" and "the State".

"L'etat c'est moi"..et toi (vous?).