Tuesday, July 21, 2009

Beale Street, Memphis Tennessee

Tennessee recently passed a law which allows concealed carry permit holders to wear their guns in bars and restaurants. Nevertheless, as MyFoxMemphis.com reports, the Beale Street Merchants have decided to ban guns.

Sunday on Beale it was fun in the sun. Where the drinks flow and the where the food comes either dry or wet.

But this weekend visitors are noticing new signs on this famous street. Tourist Joe Bazan says, "It should be up to the business owner to decide which way they wana run with that."

On Beale, the signs say it all: “Firearms are Prohibited.”

This weekend was the first weekend security and regulations were in place to enforce a new mandate banning guns on Beale. Executive Director of the Beale Street Merchants Association Onzie Horne says the security checks were in place and each night went off without a hitch, "The crowds that came to the street were happy that we instituted these measures and they were patient with us as we learn the process."

Not everyone agrees with this.

Larry Tanner says, "I think if you have a permit to conceal carry that shouldn't be allowed I believe in the 2nd amendment the right to bear arms."

Supporting the restaurant carry law they say it should be up to the patron - not the business.

Tanner says, "Were carrying legally you think that's gonna stop folks that don't have a concealed carry anyway from bringing a gun on Beale I don't think so."

What's your opinion? Is there no gun owner honest enough to admit that some people who possess the concealed carry permit get themselves in trouble around alcohol? Is it so difficult to admit that these are the people the Beale Street Merchants are trying to safeguard against? It has nothing to do with the fact that criminals don't obey the law, as Mr. Tanner says. It has everything to do with the fact that some of the law-abiding gun owners are dangerous - "some" not "most" and certainly not "all."

What do you think? The Beale Street Merchants Association is probably made up of life-long business owners who know much more about how people act in bars and restaurants than your average gun owner. Don't you think they should be able to decide?

Please leave a comment.

Monday, July 20, 2009

Concealed Carry Reciprosity - Part III

In discussing this issue, here and here, I don't think we made much progress really. There were accusations of lying, poisonous snakes were brought into it, basically it was I against the commenters, business as usual. One of them said we shouldn't be attempting to license a right anyway, and another made the obligatory comparison to cars.

Today The Gun Guys posted a press release by the Violence Policy Center.

The study, Law Enforcement and Private Citizens Killed by Concealed Handgun Permit Holders--An Analysis of News Reports, May 2007 to April 2009, finds that during the two-year period reviewed--

  • Concealed handgun permit holders have slain seven law enforcement officers resulting in criminal charges or the suicide of the shooter. All of the killings were committed with guns. An additional three law enforcement officers were injured in these incidents.

  • Concealed handgun permit holders have slain at least 44 private citizens resulting in criminal charges or the suicide of the shooter. All but one of the killings were committed with guns. An additional six private citizens were injured in these incidents.

  • In six of the 31 incidents (19 percent), the concealed handgun permit holder killed himself, bringing the total fatality count to 57.

I'd like to mention that this list of 31 incidents is not supposed to be comprehensive. So, unfortunately, it cannot be divided by the total number of license holders to ascertain a percentage of wrongdoers. It's just not that simple.

Because most state systems allowing the carrying of concealed handguns in public by private citizens release little data about crimes committed by permit holders, the VPC reviewed shooting incidents as reported by news outlets.

Another factor is these news-worthy stories involved loss of life. When you consider the woundings as well as the brandishings and incidents of threatening behaviour which are sometimes done by armed men, even supposedly responsible ones, you've got a large problem on your hands.

What's your opinion? Please leave a comment.

Released Murderer Kidnaps Family in NC

News14.com out of Charlotte North Carolina reports on a man accused of kidnapping who had already received the death penalty back in the 1980s.

Details are not clear as to his motive, but apparently Jerry Case, 52 years old, took a family of four Friday afternoon from the Belmont, N.C., area and drove them to Cherokee County in South Carolina. While pulling over for gas, police say Case got distracted, and the family got away and called 911.

Court documents show Case was originally sentenced to death in 1986 for the first-degree murder of a taxi driver. He and another man kidnapped the driver in Tennessee, drove to Gaston County and murdered him by stabbing him seven times. He was retried in August 1992, when he pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in the crime and saw his sentence reduced to life in prison. He also received 30 years for a guilty plea of second-degree kidnapping.

One thing stands out is that 25 years ago he used a knife, this week he used a gun. Do you think that's an example of the criminal progression some of our commenters talk about?

The most obvious thing is that a man like Jerry Case should never have been released from prison. Does anyone doubt what the fate of that North Carolina family would have been had they not escaped? After 22 years in prison, Case had been rehabilitated so little that within a year of his release, he did almost the same crime that put him there in the first place.

The problem is how to distinguish between the criminals who serve their sentence and can be safely released and those who continue to be dangerous and should not get out. It's a similar dilemma we have when trying to assess the difference between your average gun owner, who is safe and responsible, and the ones who are not, and should not have guns in the first place. In both cases we want to protect the public without unfairly inconveniencing the innocent.

In both cases I'm afraid we have to err on the side of caution and prudence. Violent criminals who are truly changed, the ones who find Jesus or who get involved in substance abuse programs in jail, may have to serve longer sentences in order to keep the hardened, unchanged criminals behind bars longer. In a similar way, lawful gun owners, the ones who never were a danger to anyone may have to be inconvenienced with stricter gun control laws, less flexibility in the way they buy and sell their firearms and total bans on certain types of weapons. These measures would result in the lessening of gun availability which would result in a proportional lessening in gun violence.

What's your opinion? Do you think stricter sentencing guidelines for violent criminals combined with stricter gun control regulations might be the solution? Or do you think this is just part of the price we have to pay? Most men who serve 22 years for murder don't immediately repeat their crimes when they get out. Just like most gun owners don't become criminals. The ones who do, we just need to accept, is that what you think?

Please leave a comment.

Sunday, July 19, 2009

The Real Brady Bunch

Here's a walk down memory lane thanks to Dr. Zibbs.

Tony Alamo Denies the Charges

Tony Alamo is in the news again. Last September we discussed his case when his compound was raided and he was taken into custody for child sexual abuse. Now, in response to testimony in his trial he has released a statement, basically saying the FBI coerced some of his women to lie. Included in the statement is also a fascinating description of his world view, which to me seems like exactly the kind of admission the prosecution was looking for.

The legal age of marriage is puberty. Webster’s Dictionary states childhood is the “state or time of being a child; state or time from birth or infancy to puberty or maturity.”

Webster’s definition of puberty is “the age when one becomes capable to bear children, which is marked by maturing of the reproductive organs, with the onset of menstruation in the female; the period at which sexual maturity is reached.”

The Bible says this as well. God’s Word, the Bible, never condemns a man for having more than one wife!

When we talked about the case of Warren Jeffs, I became convinced that he and his men were hiding behind their so-called religious beliefs in order to justify lustful abuse of women and young girls. To me, Tony Alamo seems to be even worse.

What's your opinion? Do you believe that in 21st century America, a man can be sincere in claiming that the proper age for marrying in young girls is the onset of menstruation? Do you think this is something the government should stay out of?

What about polygamy in general? Is there a place for that in society? Does it always have to involve underage girls? Can it sometimes be among consenting adults?

What do you think? Please leave a comment.

Family Squabbles in Tenn. / Ala. - 6 Dead (updated)

UPDATE as pointed out by several commenters, there was no mention of his using a gun. And in fact further reports confirmed none was used.

A man accused of fatally stabbing and bludgeoning six people in Tennessee and Alabama was targeting his wife and first killed her father and brother so they couldn't stop him, authorities said Tuesday.

============================================================



Yahoo News reports on the latest high profile shooting, this one in Tennessee and Alabama.

A 30-year-old man was charged with homicide Saturday in the slayings of six people, most believed to be from the same family, in two communities about 30 miles apart in Tennessee and Alabama.

Investigators said the victims were four adults and two juveniles, but their names and ages were not being released until they are identified and next of kin are notified.

Five people were found dead in two neighboring rural homes near Fayetteville in southern Tennessee Saturday, and a sixth body was discovered at a business in Huntsville, Ala., authorities said.

Jacob Shaffer of Fayetteville, who officers found sitting on the front porch of one of the homes, was taken into custody and charged with homicide. He was jailed without bond in Lincoln County, which borders Alabama.

The story contains few details except that "the motive of the killings is domestic." Unfortunately there was no mention of the weapon or weapons used or whether Shaffer was already a prohibited person.

What's your opinion? How could we keep guns out of the hands of people like this without infringing on the rights of law-abiding citizens? Is such a thing possible?

Please leave a comment.

Saturday, July 18, 2009

Concealed Carry Reciprosity - Part II

On the Brady Blog, Paul Helmke writes about the seriousness of the pending legislation regarding concealed carry, a topic we recently discussed.

Senator John Thune of North Dakota has introduced an amendment (No. 1618) to the Department of Defense appropriations authorization bill (S. 1390) , which could come up for a vote as early as Monday, July 20.

This proposal would override state law by forcing every state (except Illinois and Wisconsin) to accept the carrying of loaded, concealed firearms by non-residents of their state, even if those persons are legally barred from possessing guns in that state.

Under this proposal, states would be forced to recognize all concealed weapons permits – even if the requirements for out-of-state permit-holders fall well below their own.

Mr. Helmke uses Texas as an example of a state that has training requirements prior to the issuance of a concealed carry permit. Mississippi, on the other hand has none. Under the proposed legislation, Texas would be forced to accept Mississippi concealed carry holders visiting Texas and carry guns. There are many examples of this type of disparity between states' requirements.

But that's not the worst of it. The worst is what we refer to around here as the 10%ers. These are the supposedly lawful gun owners who for various reasons should not be trusted with a gun. Helmke itemizes several high-profile cases in which the shooter was actually in possession of a concealed carry permit.

One of the commenters on the Huffington Post, where the Helmke post is cross-published, a certain JD59, had this to say:


Well I guess I'm one of those scary people with a conceal carry permit. I am an honorably discharged veteran 49 years old. Have worked for several Gov. agencies, have a daughter in college, and a wife that works at Starbucks. Yea, I know I sound real scary.

This is typical of the pro-gun response to a serious suggestion that "[d]angerous people have concealed carry permits who shouldn't be allowed near a handgun, much less be given permission to carry one anywhere in the country."


Mr. JD59 exaggerates the comment to somehow read "all concealed carry permit holders are dangerous." He puts on that practiced self-righteous indignity and with sarcasm tries to mock the suggestion. The fact is no one ever said all gun owners are dangerous, or all concealed carry licensees should not own guns.

My theory that the problem group accounts for about 10% has been met with criticism, to say the least. Many pro-gun commenters claim the true percentage is less than 1%. I'd say a quick glance at the cases cited by Paul and the links provided in his article would suggest 10% is more like it. If anything, that estimate is probably low.

What's your opinion? Why do gun owners who are responsible and law abiding take offense at these suggestions?

Please leave a comment.