Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Concealed Carry Mania

SFGate published a wonderful article in their Business section about concealed carry laws.

I've never touched a handgun and I haven't been to Florida in decades, yet this month Florida officials mailed me a permit to carry a concealed gun.

If Congress adopts a bill that the National Rifle Association is pushing, Florida's licenses would apply to 49 states in all -- allowing their holders to carry hidden guns in places such as midtown Manhattan, where the New York Police Department rejects most such applications for "concealed- carry" permits.
Part of the discussion centers on states' rights vs. the federal government. In their usual flip-flopping way, the gun-rights folks are all for the federal government when it favors their agenda. In this case federal law would supersede state law in determining who can carry a concealed carry weapon.

Added to that is the obvious abuse of the system which allows people like the author of the article to apply for out-of-state licenses.  Utah and Florida are the meccas for this kind of legal circumvention of the law.

New York State is an extreme example, but many states have training and testing requirements before issuing licenses. Gun owners with out-of-states permits like those issued from Florida and Utah, are required to do nothing at all.

What's your opinion?  Is this right?  Wouldn't national reciprocity punish the states with stricter standards? Doesn't allowing out-of-state licenses already do that?

Please leave a comment, tell us what you think?


  1. Actually, Utah does require training. Very little training I grant you but there is still a course requirement from a Utah certified instructor.

  2. Florida requires that you show competency from having a firearms safety course.

  3. I think it's great that someone who lost his permit because he was arrested with a jammed AK-47 near an international airport. Then lies in another county, gets a permit, and changes his mind and returns that permit is allowed to get a permit in Florida.

    Of course, when the cops arrest him again, he has a valid Florida Permit.

    Nice one.

  4. BTW, I was just doing my job when I got him the acquittal.

    Isn't that a "technicality"?

  5. "Very little training I grant you" might as well be none.

    But, I thought you could get that Utah license through the mail like the Florida one.